10 Best Tasting Sugar Substitute Ideas – Go Natural Or Artificial?

* This post may contain affiliate links. When you buy through links on my site, I may earn an affiliate commission. *

The biggest concern of most coffee lovers currently is how to choose the best-tasting sugar substitute. Although coffee brings a huge load of physical advantages, for example, it can help lessen the probability of creating diabetes. However, assuming that you’re adding sugar into each cup at all times, the benefits are running low. Be that as it may, don’t worry. We’ve assembled this article for you!

Why Should You Add Sugar to Your Coffee?

What is Sugar?

It is the sweet condiment that we see almost everywhere in everyday foods. This term is the collective name of chemicals that belong to the group of carbohydrates (often abbreviated as carbs). 

But did you know that carbs and sugar are the same? They are deeply intertwined. Sugar is a carbohydrate; every carbohydrate we eat will eventually break down into sugar.

There are about 60 different variants, called under many different names. But they are all separated into two main types: natural and artificial. And it’s lurking everywhere, in almost every sweet treat.

Natural

It is divided into two main types: glucose and fructose.

Glucose is easy to find in each living thing, including our bodies. It is a natural wellspring of energy for the body. 

Fructose is obtained from food plants. It is a more complicated type, and our bodies need to separate it to make it valuable. One of the extraordinary advantages of fructose is that it expects energy to be helpful in the body and is less adept at putting away fat in the body.

Artificial

Also known as non-nutritive, they are low-calorie or non-caloric sweeteners. Artificial sweetener contains fewer calories than corn syrup and other regular types. The most well-known instances of these sweeteners are aspartame, sucralose, acesulfame potassium, neotame, and saccharin.

These items have been welcome since they give a sweet taste without increasing the body’s calories. The artificial type is a real blessing for those with diabetes or watching their weight. It permits these individuals to enjoy desserts and sodas without the caloric risks in general and poisonous impacts on the body.

Health Effects

Dental Wellbeing

Tooth rot increments with sweet overutilization. And the more you consume, the higher the risk of dental decay.

Coronary Illness

Those who have a great consumption of sweet food varieties or beverages are prone to coronary illness.

Weight Gain (Particularly Stomach Fat)

The admission of added sweeteners in refreshments and other stuff has been connected to body weight gain.

Diabetes

Research has shown the link between a high intake of sweet foods and diabetes type 2.

That’s why we should keep in mind that control is vital. It’s advisable to eat under 25 grams (6 teaspoons) of sugar each day. 

Top 10 Best Tasting Sugar Substitute Options

1. Maple Syrup

Classify: Natural

Elements: Maple syrup is high in cancer prevention agents and plentiful in minerals, including calcium, potassium, iron, zinc, and manganese. Yet, maple syrup is packed with calories and ought to be used in control.

Usage: Maple syrup is mildly sweet as honey but not too harsh, often used in place of honey. With a thick texture similar to honey, you can easily make a tasty cup of joe. We believe that maple syrup can be the best-tasting sugar substitute for your coffee.

2. Date Paste

Classify: Natural 

Elements: Dates are chock-full of fiber, minerals, and nutrients, so utilizing date paste as sugar can increase the value of your meal.

This sweetener is made from dried dates that have been ground into a coarse and slightly grainy powder. You can possibly make date paste at home in a blender, utilize 3/4 cup of water, 1/2 tsp of vanilla concentrate, and around 1 cup of warm, hollowed dates.

Usage: Dates can be especially delectable in smoothies. Use it as a substitute for table or brown sweetener to please your taste.

3. Honey

Classify: Natural 

Elements: Honey contains more supplements, including cell reinforcements, minerals, and nutrients. It’s likewise more straightforward to process and advances stomach wellbeing. 

Nonetheless, honey is high in calories and separates from glucose and fructose, possibly bringing negative effects to your health when overloaded.

Usage: Honey brewed with coffee will taste different from the regular cuppa. For those who are new, you should start with milder-tasting honey like clover honey or coffee flower honey to get used to the change.

4. Coconut Sugar

Classify: Natural 

Elements: Coconut sweetener is regularly consistently crude, so it holds every single of its nutrients and minerals. And it doesn’t cause vacillations in glucose. 

Notwithstanding, this sweetener has a similar calorie as table type. It’s still high in carbs and fructose. People who are on a diet should stay away from it. Likewise, it may not be an ideal choice for people with diabetes.

Usage: You can utilize a 1-1 ratio substitution for white sugar, so it’s not difficult to use. It tends to be extremely coarse; you might need to crush it before using it.

5. Agave Nectar

Classify: Natural

Elements: Agave nectar gives a greater number of supplements than ordinary sweeteners but less than honey. It’s extremely tasty, yet you should not use it so much. 

In any case, it contains a lot of calories and a great deal of fructose — significantly more than high-fructose corn syrup. This amount can foster weight gain, so it may not be a decent decision for those with diabetes.

Usage: Agave nectar is completely gluten-free and dissolves easily, making it the perfect choice when making your diet coffee. It brings a characteristic sweetness, enhancing the flavor of the drink. Agave nectar is better than regular sweeteners, honey, and other artificial sweeteners.

6. Monk Fruit Extracts

Classify: Novel sweetener (high intensity)

Elements: Monk natural extract might be a comparable stand-in to confine calories. You don’t have to utilize a lot since it is sweeter than sugar, about 250-300 times. It’s a non-calorie type with no unsafe secondary effects, as indicated by the FDA. 

Usage: Some observe that monk fruit extracts have a persistent flavor. With some other high-intensity, you might have to make a difference in your formula to get the best outcomes.

7. Stevia Extracts

Classify: Novel sweetener (high intensity)

Elements: Stevia is a plant extricated with practically zero calories. It is commonly known as a honey leaf or sweet leaf because it is 250 times sweeter than the usual sugar. 

People use this herb in medicine as a tonic for the heart and lower blood pressure, relieve heartburn and kidney diseases, reduce cravings for sugar and sweets in diabetes.

Usage: It has an intense flavor even after being refined, so certain individuals detest utilizing it as a sweetener for coffee or tea. 

This ingredient comes in different structures, including powder and fluid, so you might have to test to discover which ones work best in various recipes. 

8. Xylitol

Classify: Sugar alcohol

Elements: Xylitol is low-calorie. Although xylitol contains fructose, there’s no significant effect on blood sugar and insulin levels. So this ingredient is a sweetener by itself that won’t give you negative effects. Some studies suggest that xylitol may improve oral health and have many other important health perks.

Usage: You can use xylitol to replace sugar in a 1:1 ratio; if you’re a fan of sweetened coffee, this may be the right choice.

9. Sucralose

Classify: Artificial 

Elements: Sucralose acts as a non-nutritive, flavor-enhancing sweetener. When ingested, the E955 is not broken down at all but instead is directly absorbed into the bloodstream and excreted in the urine. 

There are no short or long-term effects on blood glucose control, safe for consumption by diabetics and non-diabetics. And it does not promote tooth decay.

Usage: Sucralose is suitable for people on a diet, helping the body control its shape and weight optimally. Besides, sucralose is also acceptable for people with obesity, diabetes, and high blood pressure.

10. Acesulfame Potassium

Classify: Artificial

Elements: Under normal conditions, acesulfame potassium (ace K) is 150-200 times sweeter than normal sugar. Ace K will have a slightly bitter aftertaste if you process it at a high concentration.

Usage: Ace K is often used with other sweeteners such as aspartame (synthetic sweetener E951) or sucralose (sweetener E955). This combination will help create a natural sweetness because they will lessen the bitterness compared to using them alone. You can use it in carbonated and non-carbonated beverages, coffee, or juice.

FAQs

Which sugar substitute tastes the most like sugar?

Like xylitol and inulin, erythritol tastes sweet. It looks like sucrose the most, without the severe trailing sensation found in other substitutes like saccharin, sucralose, and aspartame. Still, it is more expensive than other alternatives.

What is the safest substitute?

The best and most secure sweetener substitutes in the top 10 mentioned below are xylitol, stevia extracts. But, for all sorts, using it in a correct and enough way, there won’t be any harm.

What is the healthiest sweetener on the market?

Honey, maple syrup, and molasses are considered the healthiest substitute. All contain useful ingredients, such as proteins, nutrients, minerals, and carbs, which our body knows how to process.

To Sum Up

Table sugar is a poison that is gradually killing us, and by adding it to the coffee, we’re destroying the flavor of our espresso while shortening our lifespan. Fortunately, some best-tasting sugar substitutes to pick are better, safe, and more delicious. Are you into natural or artificial sweeteners?

Rate this post

Almost 20 years already spent committed to coffee and more than 3 years of experience as a barista at Starbucks. Madelyn Doyle graduated with a Bachelor’s Degree in Nutritional Science from the University of California and finished the Coffee Skills Program at the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA).